Looking for a magical unicorn birthday party idea that’s as pretty as it is delicious? These pastel unicorn horn vanilla frozen yogurt pops were the star of my daughter’s birthday party — and they’re surprisingly easy to make! With just a few ingredients and a touch of food coloring, you can create a batch of swirly, dreamy treats that look straight out of a fairy tale.
These DIY unicorn yogurt popsicles are not only fun for kids to make, but they’re also a healthier alternative to traditional ice cream. Perfect for summer birthdays, rainbow parties, or anytime your little one wants a taste of something magical!
✨ Ingredients
2 cups plain or vanilla yogurt (I used whole milk yogurt for creaminess)
2–3 tablespoons honey or maple syrup (optional, for sweetness)
Food coloring in pink, purple, and teal (gel or liquid)
Popsicle mold (I used a pastel green mold for an extra whimsical touch)
Popsicle sticks
🪄 Instructions
Step 1: Prep the Yogurt Base
Start with a large tub of vanilla yogurt. If you prefer your pops a little sweeter, whisk in a drizzle of honey or maple syrup. This forms your creamy base.
(In the photo above, you can see my setup — bowls of vanilla yogurt ready to be transformed into pastel magic!)
Step 2: Divide and Color
Scoop the yogurt into three bowls. Add a few drops of food coloring to each one — pink, purple, and teal. Stir until the colors are soft and even.
💡 Tip: Use pastel shades for that perfect unicorn aesthetic. You can always add more color, but you can’t take it away!
Step 3: Layer the Colors
Spoon small amounts of each color into your popsicle molds, alternating layers for a swirled, rainbow-like effect. Tap the mold gently on the counter to remove air bubbles and create smooth layers.
This step is where the magic happens — no two unicorn horns will look alike!
Step 4: Freeze
Insert the sticks and freeze overnight, or at least 4–6 hours, until solid.
Step 5: Serve & Celebrate!
When it’s party time, run the molds briefly under warm water to release the pops. Arrange them on a platter or display them in a bed of ice for a Pinterest-perfect unicorn dessert table.
At my daughter’s unicorn birthday party, these frozen yogurt pops were an instant hit. The kids loved guessing which color they’d get in each bite, and the pastel swirls matched our unicorn decorations perfectly.
💫 Why You’ll Love This Recipe
Easy to make: No blender, no baking — just mix, color, and freeze.
Kid-approved: Sweet, creamy, and mess-free.
Perfect for parties: Beautiful on any unicorn dessert table.
Healthier option: Made with real yogurt and optional natural sweeteners.
🌈 Variations
Add sprinkles before freezing for a confetti effect.
Use Greek yogurt for extra creaminess.
Try rainbow colors for a full pastel rainbow theme.
Add fruit puree like strawberry or blueberry for natural color and flavor.
📸 Make It a Memory
If you make these unicorn horn frozen yogurt pops, share your photos on Instagram and tag @GoodnightFox! I’d love to see your pastel creations.
